Mar 10, 2025 Construction DataDevelopment

Replacement Cost Reality:
Why New Builds Don't Pencil

Concrete is up 7%. Steel is rebounding. The cost to build a simple metal warehouse has decoupled from market rents. We break down the Producer Price Index (PPI) for 2025.

Every investor loves to talk about "Replacement Cost," but few run the actual numbers.

In 2025, if you want to pour a slab, erect a steel frame, and pull permits for a 10,000 SF small-bay building, you are looking at an all-in cost of $150 - $180 PSF (excluding land).

We are buying existing functional assets for $90 - $110 PSF.

The Input Costs (2024-2025)

Concrete+7.4%YoY Increase
Steel+3.8%Rebounding from '24 lows
Labor+4-5%Skilled Trades

Source: Producer Price Index (PPI) Data, AGC, JLL Construction Outlook.

The "Build vs. Buy" Spread

This spread is our margin of safety. When we buy an asset for $100 PSF, we are effectively buying it at a 33-45% discount to what a developer would have to spend to compete with us.

This does two things:

  1. Insulates Rents: A developer needs $14/SF rent to justify their $160 PSF cost. We can charge $10/SF and still make a healthy return. They cannot undercut us.
  2. Caps Supply: Because the numbers don't pencil for developers, no new supply is coming. We own a scarce commodity in a growing market.

We aren't geniuses. We just know how to read a construction bid.

Michael Holt
Michael Holt
Principal